UNSPOKEN
by Lee Becker is only 10 years old in 1935 when she sits at the double funeral for her grandmother, Alma, and baby sister, Nell, both of whom succumbed on the same day to the deadly dust plague. Ruby’s mother, Willa Mae, is frozen with grief. Just days later, Ruby falls ill with “dust pneumonia” and is hospitalized. When she recovers, her father and older brother, Will, pick her up, but they drive her the train station, not home\u003B Will is taking her to Waco, where the air is clear. He gives her $20 and leaves her with Granny Alma’s widowed cousin, Bess, with whom she is to live until the air in Hartless, Texas, is once again safe for breathing. Angry and frightened, Ruby decides the only thing in her control is her voice, and she decides to stop speaking. She hears nothing from her family, and in 1936, shortly after her 11th birthday, Cousin Bess dies. Ruby’s next stop is the Waco State Home for Dependent and Neglected Children, where she remains for seven years, despite repeated escape attempts. Playing out in tandem with Ruby’s story is that of her mother\u003B unbeknownst to Ruby, Willa Mae has been placed in the state mental facility. The mother and daughter poignantly narrate alternating chapters in Alexander’s coming\u002Dof\u002Dage Dust Bowl narrative. In vivid, graphic prose, enhanced by dialogue that reflects the dialects and linguistic patterns of the period and social station of the characters (“A red sun augurs a bad day”), the author limns the chilling cruelty of the treatment of mental patients as well as the abuses that take place at the children’s home. There are also delightful interludes, as when Eleanor Roosevelt rescues Ruby during a dust storm, or when the school nurse gives her special (marijuana) cigarettes to help her asthma. Most appealing are the tender friendships that develop at the home and on the road as Ruby gradually learns that families can be created in all sorts of ways."
Based on 72 Goodreads ratings
Book Details
Reading Info
About This Book
Without a single word of text, this picture book follows a young girl who discovers a runaway slave hidden in her family's barn during the Civil War, leaving pencil illustrations alone to carry the t...
Our Review
Without a single word of text, this picture book follows a young girl who discovers a runaway slave hidden in her family's barn during the Civil War, leaving pencil illustrations alone to carry the tension as Confederate soldiers search the property while she secretly brings food to the person hiding there. The grayscale artwork does all the narrative work most books hand to sentences, expressions, body language, subtle gestures, so a child has to actually read the pictures instead of skimming past them to find out what happens. It's a paperback with a 4.65 average across 72 Goodreads ratings.
Taking away the words turns every reader into an active participant, piecing together the danger and the girl's choices from visual clues rather than being told how to feel about them, a different kind of reading than most children get practice with. The moral weight of the story, a child choosing to help someone at real risk to her own family, gives it real substance for a conversation about courage and doing the right thing even when it's frightening, and the wordless format works across a wide range of ages and reading levels since there's no text to be too easy or too hard. It's a quiet, serious book rather than an entertaining one, worth previewing before sharing it with a sensitive child given the danger at its center.
You Might Also Like
Looking for more books?
Visit our sister site BooksbyOrder.com