Book Review: Katie the Catsitter: (A Graphic Novel)
Katie the Catsitter: A Whisker-Twitching Adventure Full of Heart
Introduction: A Purr-fect Blend of Mystery and Mayhem
Imagine a summer where your biggest responsibility is cat-sitting—except the cats in question are anything but ordinary. Katie the Catsitter by Colleen AF Venable, with vibrant illustrations by Stephanie Yue, is a middle-grade graphic novel that delivers a delightful mix of humor, mystery, and heart. If you’ve ever wished your mundane summer job could turn into a secret superhero adventure, this book is for you.
With its charming protagonist, quirky feline companions, and a plot that keeps you guessing, Katie the Catsitter stands out in the crowded world of middle-grade graphic novels. Whether you’re a young reader, a parent looking for a great book for your child, or just a fan of cozy, feel-good stories, this book is a must-read.
🔗 Get the Book: Amazon
Plot Summary: A Summer Job Like No Other
Katie is a twelve-year-old girl who dreams of going to summer camp with her best friends. But when her mom can’t afford it, Katie decides to take on a cat-sitting gig to earn money. What starts as a simple job quickly spirals into something much more bizarre when she realizes her neighbor’s 217 cats (yes, you read that right) are… unusual.
These aren’t your average house cats. They’re mischievous, highly intelligent, and seem to have secret talents—like hacking computers, operating heavy machinery, and even knitting sweaters at lightning speed. As Katie bonds with the cats (and their mysterious owner, Madeline Lang), she begins to suspect that there’s more to this job than meets the eye.
Without giving too much away, the story takes a thrilling turn when Katie stumbles upon a city-wide mystery involving a notorious group of vigilante cats and a villainous plot. The book balances slice-of-life moments with action-packed sequences, making it a page-turner from start to finish.
Character Analysis: Katie and Her Furry (and Human) Companions
Katie – The Relatable Protagonist
Katie is instantly likable—she’s resourceful, kind, and just a little bit awkward, making her a perfect stand-in for young readers. Her struggles with friendship, financial insecurity, and self-doubt make her journey deeply relatable. Watching her grow from a hesitant kid to a confident problem-solver is one of the book’s greatest strengths.
The Cats – A Cast of Quirky Personalities
Each cat has its own distinct personality, from the tech-savvy Siamese to the overly dramatic Persian. Venable and Yue do a fantastic job of making them feel like fully realized characters rather than just background props. Their antics provide endless humor, but they also play a crucial role in the story’s mystery.
Madeline Lang – The Enigmatic Neighbor
Madeline is equal parts eccentric and enigmatic. Is she just a quirky cat lady, or is there something more going on? Her dynamic with Katie adds an extra layer of intrigue to the story.
Supporting Characters – Friends and Foes
Katie’s best friends, Bethany and Patricia, add emotional depth to the story, highlighting themes of friendship and change. Meanwhile, the villains (human and feline) keep the stakes high without ever feeling too scary for younger readers.
Writing Style & Narrative Technique: A Visual and Literary Treat
Colleen AF Venable’s writing is witty, fast-paced, and packed with humor. The dialogue feels natural, especially in capturing the voice of a preteen navigating friendships and new responsibilities. Stephanie Yue’s illustrations are vibrant and expressive, bringing the cats’ personalities to life in ways that words alone couldn’t achieve.
The book’s paneling is dynamic, with action sequences that flow smoothly and quieter moments that let the emotions shine. The balance between text and visuals makes it accessible for reluctant readers while still offering depth for more advanced ones.
Themes & Deeper Meanings: More Than Just a Cat Caper
At its core, Katie the Catsitter is about:
- Friendship & Belonging – Katie’s struggle to fit in with her changing friend group is a central theme.
- Responsibility & Independence – Her summer job forces her to grow in unexpected ways.
- Economic Inequality – The book subtly addresses financial struggles without being heavy-handed.
- Heroism & Morality – What does it mean to be a hero? The story plays with this idea in fun and unexpected ways.
Personal Reading Experience: Why This Book Stuck With Me
As an adult reader, I found myself completely charmed by Katie’s world. The humor landed perfectly, the mystery kept me engaged, and the emotional beats felt genuine. It’s rare to find a book that balances lighthearted fun with deeper themes so effortlessly.
Younger readers will likely adore the cats’ antics, while parents and educators will appreciate the book’s positive messages about perseverance and kindness.
Comparisons to Other Works
Fans of Babysitters Club (graphic novel adaptations) or Hilo by Judd Winick will love Katie the Catsitter for its mix of humor and heart. It also shares DNA with Zita the Spacegirl in its adventurous spirit and strong protagonist.
Strengths & Minor Weaknesses
✅ Strengths:
- Hilarious, expressive artwork
- Well-paced mystery with great payoff
- Strong character development
- Inclusive and relatable themes
❌ Minor Weaknesses:
- Some plot points wrap up a little too neatly
- A few secondary characters could use more depth
Who Should Read This Book?
- Middle-grade readers (8-12) who love graphic novels
- Cat lovers (obviously!)
- Parents & educators looking for engaging, wholesome stories
- Fans of adventure, humor, and mystery
Final Thoughts: A Must-Read for Graphic Novel Fans
Katie the Catsitter is a joyful, clever, and heartwarming story that proves even the most ordinary summer can turn into something extraordinary. Whether you’re in it for the cats, the mystery, or Katie’s personal journey, this book delivers on all fronts.
🔗 Get the Book: Amazon
Discussion Questions for Readers:
- Which of the 217 cats would you want as a pet, and why?
- Do you think Katie made the right choices in balancing friendship and responsibility?
- If you had a secret talent like the cats, what would it be?
Have you read Katie the Catsitter? What did you think? Share your thoughts in the comments! 🐱💬
For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.
For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.