A Heartwarming Celebration of Sibling Love: Review of I Am a Big Sister by Caroline Jayne Church

Introduction: A Perfect Book for New Big Sisters

Few life changes are as monumental for a young child as welcoming a new sibling. The mix of excitement, curiosity, and uncertainty can be overwhelming—for both parents and the soon-to-be big brother or sister. Caroline Jayne Church’s I Am a Big Sister is a tender, beautifully illustrated picture book that gently guides little ones through this transition with warmth and reassurance.

If you’re looking for a book to help your child embrace their new role as an older sibling, this charming story is a must-read. With its simple yet profound message, delightful illustrations, and comforting tone, it’s no wonder this book has become a favorite among families.

In this in-depth review, we’ll explore the book’s plot, characters, themes, and why it stands out in the crowded genre of sibling-themed children’s books.

Plot Summary: A Sweet Introduction to Siblinghood

I Am a Big Sister follows a young girl as she navigates the arrival of her new baby brother or sister. The story unfolds in a series of sweet, relatable moments:

  • The little girl proudly declares her new role as a big sister.
  • She observes the baby’s smallness, noting how they cry, sleep, and need help with everything.
  • She reflects on all the things she can do that the baby can’t—yet.
  • The book reassures her that while the baby needs a lot of attention, she is still deeply loved.

The narrative is simple but effective, focusing on the child’s perspective and validating her feelings while reinforcing the joys of being an older sibling.

Character Analysis: A Relatable Little Protagonist

The unnamed big sister is the heart of the story. Church excels at capturing the voice of a young child—her curiosity, pride, and occasional uncertainty feel authentic.

  • Her Pride in Being a Big Sister – She beams with excitement over her new title, showing how much children crave responsibility and recognition.
  • Her Observations About the Baby – She notices the baby’s dependence, which helps her understand her own growth and capabilities.
  • Her Emotional Journey – While she never expresses jealousy outright, the book subtly acknowledges that adjusting to a new sibling isn’t always easy.

The baby, though mostly passive, serves as a mirror for the big sister’s reflections. Parents will appreciate how the book validates both the joys and challenges of sibling dynamics.

Writing Style & Illustrations: Warm, Engaging, and Perfect for Little Readers

Caroline Jayne Church’s writing is gentle, rhythmic, and reassuring, making it ideal for toddlers and preschoolers. The sentences are short and repetitive, which helps young readers follow along and even “read” along with caregivers.

The illustrations are the book’s standout feature:

  • Soft, Pastel Colors – The artwork has a cozy, comforting feel, with warm hues that evoke love and security.
  • Expressive Characters – The big sister’s facial expressions—pride, wonder, and affection—are beautifully rendered.
  • Inclusive Representation – While the family isn’t racially specified, the art is welcoming and could resonate with diverse families.

Church’s signature style—round-faced, rosy-cheeked children—adds to the book’s universal appeal.

Themes & Deeper Meanings: More Than Just a Sibling Story

At its core, I Am a Big Sister is about love, growth, and belonging. Some key themes include:

  • The Joy of Responsibility – The book frames being a big sister as a privilege, not a burden.
  • Patience & Understanding – It acknowledges that babies need time and care, helping older siblings feel involved rather than left out.
  • Unconditional Love – The repeated reassurance that “Mommy and Daddy love us both” is a powerful message for children adjusting to change.

Unlike some sibling books that focus heavily on jealousy, this one keeps the tone positive while still acknowledging the adjustment period.

Personal Reading Experience: Why This Book Resonates

As a parent who has read this book countless times to my own child, I can attest to its magic. My daughter, who became a big sister at three, loved pointing out all the things she could do that the baby couldn’t—it gave her a sense of pride during a time of big emotions.

What makes I Am a Big Sister special is its gentle approach. It doesn’t dismiss a child’s feelings but instead celebrates their new role in a way that feels empowering.

Comparison to Other Sibling Books

Many books tackle the new-sibling theme, but I Am a Big Sister stands out for its:

  • Positivity – Unlike Julius, the Baby of the World (which leans into sibling rivalry), this book focuses on love and pride.
  • Simplicity – It’s more straightforward than The New Baby (by Mercer Mayer), making it better for younger toddlers.
  • Gender Neutrality – While this version is I Am a Big Sister, Church also offers I Am a Big Brother, making it inclusive for all families.

Strengths & Minor Weaknesses

Strengths:

✅ Perfect for Toddlers – Simple text and engaging illustrations hold young attention spans.
✅ Reassuring Tone – Helps ease anxiety about a new sibling.
✅ Durable Board Book Format – Great for little hands.

Minor Weaknesses:

❌ Very Basic Plot – Some parents might want a more detailed story.
❌ Limited Conflict – Doesn’t address jealousy as explicitly as some other books.

Who Should Read This Book?

  • Parents expecting a second child (best for ages 2-4).
  • Caregivers looking for a gentle, uplifting sibling story.
  • Fans of Caroline Jayne Church’s other books (Good Night, I Love You; You Are My Sunshine).

Memorable Quotes

“I am a big sister. The baby is little. I can do lots of things the baby can’t do yet!”

“Mommy and Daddy love us both—so much!”

Final Verdict: A Must-Have for New Big Sisters

I Am a Big Sister is a heartfelt, beautifully crafted book that helps little ones embrace their new role with confidence and joy. Its reassuring message, charming illustrations, and toddler-friendly format make it a perfect gift for growing families.

If you’re preparing your child for a new sibling, this book is a wonderful way to start the conversation.

🔗 Get the Book: Amazon

Discussion Questions for Readers:

  • How did your child react to this book?
  • What other sibling-prep books have you found helpful?
  • Did the illustrations resonate with your little one?

Let’s chat in the comments! 📚💬

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.