Book Review: When Someone You Love Has Died: Talking to Young Children About Death
A Compassionate Guide for Grieving Families: Review of When Someone You Love Has Died by Stephanie Seidler
Introduction: A Much-Needed Resource for Difficult Conversations
Death is an inevitable part of life, yet discussing it with young children remains one of the most daunting challenges for parents, caregivers, and educators. How do you explain loss in a way that a child can understand without overwhelming them? Stephanie Seidler’s When Someone You Love Has Died: Talking to Young Children About Death is a tender, insightful, and practical guide that bridges this gap with remarkable sensitivity.
Unlike many books on grief that focus solely on adult perspectives, Seidler’s work is uniquely tailored to help adults navigate these painful conversations with children. Whether you’re a grieving parent, a teacher, or a counselor, this book offers a gentle yet structured approach to discussing death in an age-appropriate manner.
Plot Summary: A Framework for Healing Conversations
While not a narrative-driven book, When Someone You Love Has Died is structured as a step-by-step guide that walks adults through the process of explaining death to children. Seidler breaks down complex emotions and abstract concepts into digestible, child-friendly explanations.
The book covers:
- How to explain death in concrete terms (avoiding euphemisms like “passed away” that may confuse children)
- Addressing common fears and misconceptions (e.g., “Will I die too?”)
- Helping children express their grief through words, art, and play
- Practical advice for funerals and memorials (how to prepare a child for what they might see and feel)
- Long-term support strategies (recognizing delayed grief responses)
Each chapter builds on the last, offering both psychological insights and actionable steps.
Character Analysis & Development: The Child’s Perspective
Though this is a nonfiction guide, Seidler effectively “characterizes” the grieving child by anticipating their emotional responses. She emphasizes that children process grief differently than adults—often in bursts of emotion followed by seemingly unaffected behavior.
Key insights include:
- Young children may not grasp permanence, leading to repeated questions like, “When is Grandma coming back?”
- Guilt is common—children may blame themselves for a loved one’s death.
- Regression (bedwetting, clinginess) is normal and should be met with patience.
Seidler’s approach validates a child’s feelings while providing adults with the language to reassure them.
Writing Style & Narrative Technique: Clear, Compassionate, and Accessible
Seidler’s writing is warm, direct, and free of jargon, making it accessible to readers who may be grieving themselves. She uses:
- Simple analogies (e.g., comparing death to a stopped clock to explain the finality of life)
- Scripted dialogues (showing exactly how to phrase difficult explanations)
- Bullet points and summaries for quick reference during emotional moments
Her tone never feels clinical; instead, it reads like a wise friend offering a steadying hand.
Themes & Deeper Meanings: Beyond the Basics of Grief
While the book’s primary focus is helping children, it subtly addresses adult grief as well. Many parents struggle with their own sorrow while trying to stay strong for their kids. Seidler gently reminds readers that it’s okay to show emotion—crying in front of a child can model healthy grieving.
Key themes include:
- Honesty vs. protection (how much should a child know?)
- Cultural and religious considerations (tailoring explanations to family beliefs)
- Continuing bonds (keeping memories alive without fostering denial)
Personal Reading Experience: A Book I Wish I’d Had Sooner
As someone who lost a parent young, I found myself nodding along to Seidler’s advice. I remember being told, “Dad is sleeping,” which only fueled nightmares. This book would have spared me (and my family) so much confusion.
Reading it now as an adult, I was struck by how practical yet profound the guidance is. One passage that resonated deeply:
“Children need truth wrapped in love. Avoiding the word ‘dead’ doesn’t shield them from pain—it just leaves them alone with their questions.”
Comparison to Other Books in the Genre
Most grief books for children are storybooks (e.g., The Invisible String by Patrice Karst) or workbooks (The Grieving Child by Helen Fitzgerald). Seidler’s guide stands out because it’s written for adults to use as a teaching tool.
It’s closest in spirit to Talking About Death by Earl Grollman but is more modern and interactive, with prompts for family discussions.
Strengths & Minor Weaknesses
Strengths:
✔ Age-specific advice (toddlers vs. school-age kids)
✔ Inclusive of diverse beliefs (secular and religious perspectives)
✔ Balances theory with real-world scripts
Weaknesses:
✖ Could use more visual aids (some parents might prefer illustrated guides)
✖ Limited focus on traumatic death (e.g., suicide, violence)
Target Audience: Who Should Read This?
This book is ideal for:
- Parents and grandparents navigating a family loss
- Teachers and counselors supporting grieving students
- Foster/adoptive parents helping children process past trauma
It’s less suited for teens (who may need more advanced resources) or those seeking a memoir-style grief book.
Memorable Quotes & Passages
“Grief is not a problem to be solved but a journey to be accompanied.”
“When a child asks, ‘Why did they die?’ sometimes the best answer is, ‘I don’t know, but I’m here with you.’”
Cultural & Historical Context
Seidler’s approach reflects modern child psychology, moving away from the “shield children from sadness” mindset of past generations. She also acknowledges diverse mourning practices, making the book adaptable across cultures.
Final Thoughts: A Lifeline for Grieving Families
When Someone You Love Has Died is more than a book—it’s a toolkit for healing. Seidler’s compassionate, no-nonsense guidance removes the fear from these conversations, replacing it with clarity and love.
If you’re struggling to explain loss to a child, this book will give you the words when yours fail.
🔗 Get the Book: Amazon
Discussion Questions for Readers:
- How did your family talk about death when you were a child?
- What’s the most helpful thing an adult said to you after a loss?
- If you’ve read this book, which strategies worked best for your family?
Let’s keep the conversation going in the comments! 💙
For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.
For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.