The Girl Who Makes a Million Mistakes: A Growth Mindset Book for Kids – A Thoughtful Review

Introduction: Why This Book Matters

In a world where perfection is often glorified, The Girl Who Makes a Million Mistakes by Brenda Li is a refreshing, empowering read for children (and even adults!) who struggle with self-doubt. This heartwarming, illustrated book isn’t just a story—it’s a toolkit for resilience, teaching kids that mistakes aren’t failures but stepping stones to growth.

As a parent, educator, or young reader, you’ve likely encountered books about perseverance. But what makes this one special? Its relatable protagonist, engaging storytelling, and powerful message make it stand out in the crowded genre of growth mindset books for kids.

Let’s dive deep into why this book deserves a spot on your shelf—and why it might just become a favorite for bedtime reading or classroom discussions.

Plot Summary: A Journey of Mistakes and Growth

The Girl Who Makes a Million Mistakes follows Millie, a bright but self-conscious girl who believes she’s “bad at everything” because she keeps messing up. Whether it’s tripping in gym class, misspelling words in school, or burning cookies at home, Millie feels like she can’t do anything right.

But with the help of her supportive parents, encouraging teacher, and a wise mentor (who may or may not be a talking squirrel—no spoilers here!), Millie learns that mistakes are part of learning. The story takes her through small but meaningful challenges, showing how persistence and self-compassion lead to progress.

Without giving away major plot twists, the book beautifully balances humor, struggle, and triumph, making it both entertaining and instructive.

Character Analysis: Why Millie Feels Real

Millie – The Relatable Heroine

Millie isn’t a superhero—she’s an everyday kid with fears and frustrations. Her internal monologue (“Why can’t I get this right?”) will resonate with any child (or adult!) who’s ever felt inadequate. What makes her compelling is her gradual shift from self-criticism to self-encouragement.

Supporting Characters – The Cheerleaders and Guides

  • Millie’s Parents: Unlike some children’s books where parents are absent or overly critical, Millie’s mom and dad are nurturing but realistic. They don’t just say, “You’re perfect!”—they acknowledge her struggles while reinforcing effort over results.
  • The Teacher/Mentor: A key figure who introduces the concept of a “growth mindset” in a way that feels organic, not preachy.
  • The Talking Squirrel (or Is It?): A whimsical touch that adds humor and lightness to Millie’s journey.

Writing Style & Narrative Technique: Engaging and Accessible

Brenda Li’s writing is clear, warm, and conversational, making it perfect for young readers (ages 6-10). The book avoids heavy-handed moralizing, instead letting Millie’s experiences speak for themselves.

Key strengths:

  • Short, digestible chapters – Great for reluctant readers.
  • Playful illustrations – Enhances emotional connection.
  • Dialogue-driven storytelling – Keeps the pace lively.

If you’ve read The Most Magnificent Thing by Ashley Spires or Beautiful Oops! by Barney Saltzberg, you’ll appreciate Li’s similar blend of simplicity and depth.

Themes & Deeper Meanings: More Than Just a Story

At its core, this book tackles:

  1. Growth Mindset vs. Fixed Mindset – The idea that abilities improve with effort.
  2. Self-Compassion – Learning to be kind to yourself when things go wrong.
  3. Resilience in Small Steps – Progress isn’t about huge wins but consistent trying.

Unlike some children’s books that oversimplify (“Just believe in yourself!”), this one acknowledges frustration while offering practical coping strategies.

Personal Reading Experience: Why It Stuck With Me

I read this with my 8-year-old niece, who’s a perfectionist about her art. When Millie grumbled, “I’ll never be good at this,” my niece gasped and said, “That’s me!” By the end, she was nodding along: “So it’s okay if my drawing isn’t perfect yet.”

That’s the magic of this book—it validates struggles while offering hope.

Comparison to Other Growth Mindset Books

How does it stack up?

  • Vs. The Dot by Peter Reynolds: Both celebrate creativity, but Million Mistakes focuses more on daily struggles.
  • Vs. Giraffes Can’t Dance by Giles Andreae: Similar themes, but Li’s book includes more actionable reflection points (e.g., “What did you learn from this mistake?”).

Strengths & Minor Weaknesses

Strengths:

✅ Authentic voice – Millie’s frustrations feel real.
✅ Balance of fun and lesson – Never feels like a textbook.
✅ Diverse representation – Inclusive without being forced.

Weaknesses:

❌ Predictable for older kids – Teens might find it simplistic.
❌ Could use more “try this” exercises – A workbook companion would be amazing!

Who Should Read This?

Perfect for:

  • Kids 6-10 struggling with confidence.
  • Parents/Teachers wanting to discuss resilience.
  • Fans of The Magical Yet or Ish by Peter Reynolds.

Not ideal for:

  • Older kids seeking complex plots.
  • Readers who prefer non-illustrated chapter books.

Memorable Quotes

“Mistakes aren’t monsters under the bed—they’re teachers in disguise.”

“You’re not ‘bad at this.’ You’re just ‘still learning.’”

Final Verdict: A Must-Read for Young Learners

The Girl Who Makes a Million Mistakes is more than a book—it’s a conversation starter about perseverance. Brenda Li crafts a story that’s equal parts entertaining and empowering, making it a standout in children’s growth mindset literature.

Whether you’re a parent, educator, or a kid who’s ever felt discouraged, this book is a gentle, uplifting reminder that mistakes are proof you’re trying.

🔗 Get the Book: Amazon

Discussion Questions for Readers:

  1. What’s a mistake you’ve made that taught you something?
  2. How do you talk to yourself when things go wrong?
  3. Who’s your “support squad” when you’re struggling?

Have you read this book? Share your thoughts in the comments!

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.