Family of Liars: The Prequel to We Were Liars – A Haunting Dive into Secrets and Betrayal

Introduction: A Sinister Return to the Sinclair Family

E. Lockhart’s We Were Liars left readers stunned with its twisty narrative and emotional gut-punch ending. Now, with Family of Liars, Lockhart takes us back to the cursed Sinclair family—this time, decades earlier—to uncover the dark roots of their deception. If you loved the atmospheric tension and unreliable narration of We Were Liars, this prequel delivers the same intoxicating blend of family drama, psychological suspense, and lyrical prose.

But does Family of Liars stand on its own, or does it rely too heavily on its predecessor? Let’s dive deep into this haunting tale of privilege, grief, and the lies we tell to survive.

Plot Summary: A Summer of Secrets

Family of Liars follows Carrie Sinclair, the mother of We Were Liars’ protagonist, during a fateful summer in her youth. The Sinclair family—wealthy, beautiful, and deeply flawed—returns to their private island, Beechwood, where tragedy strikes when Carrie’s cousin dies in a drowning accident.

Grief-stricken and struggling with addiction, Carrie finds solace in a group of mysterious boys who arrive on the island. As she becomes entangled in their world, secrets unravel, and the Sinclair family’s carefully constructed façade begins to crack. The story unfolds with the same slow-burning tension as We Were Liars, leading to a shocking climax that reshapes everything we thought we knew about the Sinclairs.

Lockhart masterfully avoids major spoilers for We Were Liars, making this prequel accessible to new readers while rewarding longtime fans with deeper insights into the family’s twisted legacy.

Character Analysis: The Flawed, Fascinating Sinclairs

Carrie Sinclair – A Tragic Unreliable Narrator

Carrie is a deeply compelling protagonist—privileged yet broken, sharp yet self-destructive. Her grief over her sister’s death drives her toward reckless decisions, and her narration is tinged with denial, making her an unreliable guide through the story. Lockhart excels at crafting characters who are both sympathetic and frustrating, and Carrie is no exception.

The Supporting Cast – A Web of Lies

The Sinclair siblings—Penny, Bess, and the ghostly presence of Rosemary—are vividly drawn, each hiding their own pain behind a veneer of perfection. The visiting boys, particularly Pfeff and Yardley, add an element of danger and unpredictability. Their relationships with Carrie blur the lines between love and manipulation, keeping readers guessing about their true intentions.

Writing Style & Narrative Technique: Lyrical and Unsettling

Lockhart’s prose is as sharp and evocative as ever. She employs:

  • Fragmented storytelling: Short, punchy chapters mirror Carrie’s fractured mental state.
  • Poetic repetition: Certain phrases echo throughout, reinforcing themes of memory and denial.
  • Unreliable narration: Like We Were Liars, the truth is slippery, forcing readers to question every revelation.

The writing is lush yet unsettling, immersing us in the Sinclair world while keeping us at arm’s length—just like the family itself.

Themes: Privilege, Grief, and the Cost of Lies

The Corrosive Nature of Wealth

The Sinclairs’ wealth isolates them, allowing their dysfunction to fester. Their island is both a paradise and a prison, a metaphor for how privilege can trap as much as it protects.

Grief and Denial

Carrie’s addiction and recklessness stem from unprocessed grief. Lockhart explores how families bury pain instead of confronting it—leading to generational cycles of trauma.

The Lies We Tell Ourselves

The title Family of Liars isn’t just dramatic flair—it’s the core of the story. The Sinclairs lie to protect themselves, but those lies become chains.

Personal Reading Experience: A Slow Burn That Lingers

I’ll admit, Family of Liars didn’t grip me as immediately as We Were Liars. The first half is atmospheric but slow, focusing on character dynamics rather than plot. However, once the secrets start unraveling, I couldn’t put it down. The ending left me reeling—Lockhart has a way of making even the most shocking twists feel inevitable in hindsight.

Emotionally, it’s a heavy read. Carrie’s pain is visceral, and the Sinclair family’s toxicity is both fascinating and heartbreaking. If you love books that explore dark family dynamics (think The Secret History or Sharp Objects), this will resonate deeply.

Comparison to Other Works in the Genre

Fans of:

  • We Were Liars (obviously)
  • The Cousins by Karen M. McManus (wealthy family secrets)
  • The Summer I Turned Pretty (but make it dark)
  • The Secret History (academic elitism meets psychological suspense)

Family of Liars stands out for its poetic prose and deeply flawed characters, though it lacks the immediate punch of We Were Liars.

Strengths & Minor Weaknesses

✅ Strengths:

  • Gorgeous, immersive writing
  • Complex, morally gray characters
  • A twist that reframes We Were Liars in a new light

❌ Weaknesses:

  • Pacing drags in the first half
  • Some readers may find Carrie frustrating (though that’s intentional)

Target Audience: Who Should Read This?

🔹 Fans of We Were Liars who want more Sinclair lore
🔹 Readers who love dark family sagas
🔹 Those who enjoy unreliable narrators and psychological suspense
🔹 YA/New Adult readers who appreciate lyrical, literary writing

Not recommended for readers who dislike slow burns or open-ended conclusions.

Memorable Quotes

“We are liars, all of us. We lie to others, and we lie to ourselves.”

“Grief is love turned inside out.”

“The island knows what we did. It always has.”

Final Verdict: A Haunting, Worthy Prequel

Family of Liars doesn’t surpass We Were Liars, but it enriches the original story with deeper layers of tragedy and deceit. Lockhart’s writing is as sharp as ever, and Carrie’s journey is one that lingers long after the last page.

If you’re ready to return to Beechwood Island—where the water is blue, the lies are deep, and the Sinclair family’s secrets are darker than ever—this book is for you.

🔗 Get the Book: Amazon

Discussion Questions for Readers:

  • Did you predict the twist? How does it change your view of We Were Liars?
  • Which Sinclair sibling do you think is the most tragic?
  • How does Lockhart use setting (the island) as a character in itself?

Let me know your thoughts in the comments! 📖✨

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.